GoKunming

Forums

"One Belt One Road" and its role in Yunnan

cloudtrapezer (657 posts) • -1

If you say so Jan but I can just as easily imagine it may have the opposite effect. People might say to themselves why spend all this money helping foreigners (and that's the way they would see it). What about us?

JanJal (875 posts) • +1

@cloudtrapezer: "People might say to themselves why spend all this money helping foreigners (and that's the way they would see it)."

Chinese government does not market it as foreign aid, not in same way as (for example) USA or European countries label their aid to Africa or elsewhere.

China sells it as investment, which I think it mostly is. There is expected return for those investments, that is supposed to benefit also China and therefore Chinese people.

In Africa for example, China is investing to local manufacturing and agriculture, but they reportedly require earmarking production for shipping to China. China wants to see this as win-win situation.

cloudtrapezer (657 posts) • 0

Jan you always want the last word but I wasn't talking about government marketing but ordinary people's perceptions. They're two entirely different things. That's my last word on this at any rate.

JanJal (875 posts) • +1

It is not a competition. If I want to say something, I say it. I hope others can too.

Governments have to market programs like this not only to their buyers and possible outside evaluators, but also to their own people.

You brought this question up yourself: "People might say to themselves why spend all this money helping foreigners "

People won't say such, if the government sells it to them in right way, and that is easy in country where the state controls media like it does in China. Should there be too loud opposing voices anyway, they can be quickly silenced as well.

BRI needs to be justified to Chinese people, just like western governments need to justify their foreign aid budgets or whatever investments abroad to their people.

On that note, it should be remembered that until quite recently (and still now I believe), China itself was a recipient of foreign aid both from UN and individual countries. Though it gies more foreign aid out than it receives.

Of course, especially with aid from individual countries, it can be questioned what the motives behind some of that aid is.

But BRI is not about foreign aid, it is investments with expected returns.

Login to post Register to post