Earlier this week, Chinese news outlet Xinhua published an article outlining how Shangri-la, a mountain town in northwest Yunnan, is scrambling to recover two years after a devastating fire. The report paints the picture of an area rebuilt with huge amounts of government money that has so far failed to attract enough tourists for the local economy to bounce back.
As we had not visited since the 2014 fire that destroyed more than 300 Tibetan-style homes and businesses, we were curious to see if such characterizations were true. To find out more, we contacted business owners living in Shangri-la to see how they would describe the city's recovery, especially in the old town, called Dukezong (独克宗).
The Xinhua article cites one shop owner who says his business is down nearly 90 percent since the fire. The report goes on to quote unnamed government officials who "don't expect a significant increase in tourist numbers over the summer", when visits are typically at their highest. So, in a town that 15 years ago changed its name from Zhongdian (中甸) to Shangri-la (香格里拉) specifically to attract more tourists, is the situation as dire as portrayed? Turns out, it's complicated.
Joel Simbrow, owner and operator of The New Town Raven bar generally agrees with the Xinhua article assessment, although he remains optimistic for the long term:
I do not expect tourism to recover anywhere near one hundred percent this year, I don't think anyone does. There are just too many rumors around China, with people [saying] the whole city burned down...They're building a new high-speed railway and highway up here, though, so I would say three to five years [for a complete recovery].
There are also those who figure Shangri-la's turnaround will take far less time and indeed is already well underway. The provincial government has spent 900 million yuan (US$138.3 million) on reconstruction and fire-proofing measures over the previous two years, with an additional 300 million (US$46 million) earmarked for further improvements.
Songtsen (Sonny) Gyalzur, founder and chairman of Shangri-la Highland Craft Brewery, believes the money has been well-spent and tourist interest in the town is rebounding. "I think they're building the old town now better than before. So I see it as optimistic and positive...and the insights I get from tour guides look quite positive. So I hope we will have a better tourism season than last year," he says.
Rebuilding and basically rebranding has worked in other Yunnan cities devastated by disasters, most notably in tourist haven Lijiang. However, 1,300 year-old Shangri-la may have a much more difficult time attracting new domestic travelers. For starters, the town remains fairly remote and sits at 3,160 meters above sea level. "It's a tough tourist spot, always has been. It's a little too high for many Chinese, a little bit too cold," says Simbrow.
Reconstruction and renovation work continues unabated, and Gyalzur and Simbrow are both optimistic, just on different timelines. The two business owners both concluded their comments to GoKunming the same way, saying, "We'll see." Now the waiting game for the summer tourist season begins.
Images: Xinhua© Copyright 2005-2022 GoKunming.com all rights reserved. This material may not be republished, rewritten or redistributed without permission.